Contact us today!
(800) 588-4430

Telesys Voice and Data Blog

Telesys Voice and Data has been serving the Fort Worth area since 1994, providing IT Support such as technical helpdesk support, computer support, and consulting to small and medium-sized businesses.

Should Companies Be Punished for Data Breaches?

Should Companies Be Punished for Data Breaches?

We’ve all seen and heard about companies and government departments that have experienced major security and data loss events. Once the event is made public, there is a media frenzy of coverage disclosing answers to questions like: Were your records compromised? How can you protect nonpublic information in the future? What should you do if you are a victim? However, as the media focus moves to another topic, the breach becomes yesterday’s news - and there is very little coverage of what repercussions and penalties those entities that were breached faced - if any.

The United States Federal Government determined that general data breach events were ‘sectoral’, meaning that each state where at least one victim resides have the jurisdiction to create and enforce laws regarding general data breaches and security. When a breach occurs, offenders are normally required to give notification to that state's Attorney General, who then determines if the state will seek further action against the offending party.

The U.S. government has only stepped-in so far as to protect two specific-categories of nonpublic information; medical information, through the Healthcare Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), and financial information, through the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA). Even though these laws were established in the late 1990s, their application to information technology is still being explored by the court system. Compared to many other types of crime, prosecuting a data breach is still new, with federal courts having just completed a trial for the first time, in 2015.

Other parts of the world have already seen the importance of a unified standard for regulating data protection, breach prevention, investigation, and violation. The European Union has already passed a ‘General Data Protection Regulation’ which goes into effect in May 2018. In addition to giving data protection authorities more power and resources to investigate and enforce the law, the fines for an offending organization are $20 million or 4% of their revenue - whichever is the larger amount of money.

The secular responsibility of data security laws has lead to some pretty extreme variations among how breaches are handled by the United States. For example, it is the discretion of the state whether they choose to penalize the offending company per violation (records lost), per series of breaches (all charged as a single breach event), or, as impractical as it sounds, per resident. Furthermore, even if they’re prosecuted for their actions that led to the breach (or inactions in some cases), only four states and the District of Columbia give their Attorney Generals the explicit right to collect restitution. Those states are Arkansas, Illinois, Nevada, and Pennsylvania.

Additionally, many states completely bar individuals and organizations from taking independent action against the entity that had been breached, even if said entity is not prosecuted by the state or ordered to pay any type of restitution.

In what could be the most severe repercussion of all the possible punishments for a data breach, is the right of a state to file an injunction against offending businesses, forcing them to freeze operations, pending an investigation of the event. For many companies, the losses associated with indefinitely halting production, combined with damage to their reputation, will exceed any fines or restitution ordered by the court.

The good news is that many states have proposed new legislation or adjusted statutes to reflect the increasingly digital climate of the business world. In fact, a few progressive states have already implemented clarifying the exact amount of time allowed before an entity must notify the Attorney General of that state, as well as setting parameters for the maximum number of records stolen before breach notification is required. For example, Rhode Island law compels breached organizations to notify the Attorney General if five hundred or more records are compromised.

The reality is that, for the most part, cybercrime and data loss laws are a bit behind the technology. In many cases, states have found that by the time an act goes through legislation and becomes a statute, the technology that the laws were created for is outdated. After all, if we can access an infinite world of information immediately, perhaps it’s time to reconsider lengthy legislative processes.

What is your opinion on data breach laws? Should the federal government have a general data loss notification policy, or are the states the best choice to determine how to handle a breach?


No comments yet
Already Registered? Login Here
Monday, 20 November 2017
If you'd like to register, please fill in the username, password and name fields.

Captcha Image

Blog Archive

Free Consultation

Sign up today for a
FREE Network Consultation

How secure is your IT infrastructure?
Let us evaluate it for free!

Sign up Now!

Free Consultation

Tag Cloud

Security Tip of the Week Technology Best Practices Cloud Hackers Privacy Business Computing Productivity Malware Business Microsoft Email Windows 10 Internet Backup Hosted Solutions Computer IT Services Network Security Workplace Tips Software User Tips Smartphone Ransomware Managed Service Provider Android Google IT Support Mobile Devices Social Media Business Continuity Hardware Communication Disaster Recovery Managed IT services App Efficiency Browser Office Data Innovation Microsoft Office Windows Data Management Facebook Remote Monitoring Smartphones Upgrade Miscellaneous WiFi Office 365 Network Big Data Holiday Gmail Password Small Business Internet of Things Robot Apps Phishing Hosted Solution Recovery Spam Employer-Employee Relationship Productivity Server Risk Management Apple Artificial Intelligence Avoiding Downtime Tip of the week Word Unified Threat Management Cloud Computing Hacker Customer Service Firewall Mobile Device Management How To Content Filtering Save Money Outsourced IT Data Backup Work/Life Balance Office Tips Settings Health Computers Alert Telephone Systems Hacking Data storage Computing Cybersecurity IT Support Education Operating System Managed IT Services Cybercrime Business Management Saving Money Remote Computing SaaS Money Presentation Business Growth Encryption Social Customer Relationship Management Outlook Passwords Data Recovery Chrome LiFi Two-factor Authentication Retail File Sharing Twitter Best Practice Politics Monitors Analytics Vendor Management Lithium-ion battery Google Drive Windows 10 Business Owner The Internet of Things Websites Physical Security Going Green Taxes Marketing IBM Running Cable Botnet Printing Mobile Computing Samsung Competition Tech Support Bandwidth Bring Your Own Device Search Sports Virtual Private Network Information Technology IT service Cortana Computer Care Humor Virtualization Administration Virtual Reality Training Government Analyitcs Safety Maintenance VoIP IT solutions IT Management Paperless Office BYOD Wireless Technology Wireless Automobile Upgrades Budget Downtime End of Support Antivirus Website Wi-Fi communications Mouse Mobile Device YouTube User Data loss Collaboration Legal Tablet Mobile Data Superfish iPhone Hacks VoIP Staffing business communications systems Touchscreen Multi-Factor Security BDR Disaster Shortcut Scam Current Events Digital GPS Travel G Suite Processors Internet Protocol Laptop Google Calendar Hard Drives Google Maps Uninterrupted Power Supply Virtual Desktop Automation Patch Management Networking Augmented Reality Spyware Tracking Motion Sickness VoIP streamlines Halloween Google Docs Legislation Refrigeration Solid State Drive PowerPoint Writing Vulnerability Deep Learning Personal Information Data Security Fun How To Document Management IT Consultant business network infrastructure Scary Stories Heating/Cooling Consumers VPN Hard Disk Drive Machine Learning Social Engineering Computer Repair Techology Firefox Identity Theft Meetings Cleaning Notifications data services Storage Servers Undo eWaste IP Address Relocation Alt Codes Electronic Medical Records Disaster Resistance Google Wallet Assessment Supercomputer IT Sevices Webcam Help Desk Crowdsourcing User Error Dark Data Server Management Mail Merge Environment Mobile Office Private Cloud Typing Proactive IT Drones Consultation IT Budget Point of Sale Licensing Printer Buisness Statistics Address Troubleshooting Error Cryptocurrency IT Consulting Knowledge Digital Payment Software Tips Bluetooth Project Management Corporate Profile Phone System Bitcoin Update Data Breach Experience Quick Tips Access Control Web Server Specifications Business Technology WannaCry Administrator 3D Printing Windows 8 Chromebook Technology Laws Time Management SharePoint Cameras Cabling Law Enforcement Network Congestion Managed IT Domains Lenovo 5G Entrepreneur Unified Communications Unsupported Software CCTV Emoji Unified Threat Management Network Management Downloads Application Infrastructure Gadget Users Display Public Speaking

Top Blog

Don't be Afraid to Replace Got an older PC that's causing you a lot of issues? Older technology is typically more expensive to run, and after a while, it's cheaper to simply buy a new desktop than it is to continue pouring money into something that always seems broken. It's a great time to buy wo...